Improper Vs Proper Paraphrasing: What Counts As Plagiarism?

Paraphrasing serves as a method to reframe existing text using different wording while preserving its core message. This practice is commonly employed in academic writing, enabling the communication of key concepts more succinctly while retaining the essence of the source material. 

However, paraphrasing can inadvertently lead to plagiarism if not executed carefully. It’s essential to acknowledge the source while remaining faithful to its intended meaning. By conducting thorough research and employing effective techniques, writers can generate unique and original content. This article is designed to provide insights into distinguishing between different paraphrasing methods to mitigate the risk of plagiarism. 

Proper Paraphrasing

Proper paraphrasing is a critical skill in academic writing, requiring writers to reframe original ideas in their own words while preserving the intended meaning. This process involves thorough comprehension of source material, meticulous note-taking, and summarization to ensure accuracy. 

Effective paraphrasing not only demonstrates an understanding of complex concepts but also the ability to articulate them clearly. In academic writing, it’s vital to use quotation marks judiciously and preferentially to integrate the original author’s ideas through paraphrasing. Moreover, accurate citation of the original source is paramount for upholding academic integrity, as failure to do so can lead to accusations of plagiarism with serious consequences.

Example:

In this paraphrased version, the essence of the original text about the impact of smartphones on communication and the versatility brought about by mobile apps is retained. However, different words and sentence structures are used to convey the same message. Also, the paraphrased version includes proper citations to acknowledge the source.

Improper Paraphrasing 

Improper paraphrasing, a common form of plagiarism, involves taking direct phrases from another work, making minimal alterations, and presenting them as original. It also occurs when individuals use another’s ideas, language, or the same sentence structure without acknowledgment. This might involve closely replicating the original content with minor changes or summarizing without citation. 

Essentially, improper paraphrasing deceives readers into believing that the content is original when, in fact, it is derived from another source without proper attribution.

Example:

The improperly paraphrased version retains the central idea of smartphones revolutionizing communication and becoming multifunctional devices due to mobile apps. However, the wording and structure have been changed slightly without properly rephrasing the original text. 

Also, there is one thing to notice the citation is also included in the paraphrased version but still, it failed to prevent plagiarism due to improper paraphrasing. 

When is Paraphrasing Plagiarism?

Paraphrasing, when not accompanied by proper citation, can indeed lead to plagiarism, particularly when writers fail to acknowledge the original author and source. This oversight is common among students who utilize materials from libraries, journals, or online sources without adequate attribution. 

Failure to do so can result in serious consequences such as academic penalties, suspension, or even expulsion, affecting one’s academic and professional future. 

To illustrate the disparities between paraphrasing and plagiarism, consider the following comparison:

Paraphrasing Plagiarism
Aims to reword the original text Uses direct quoting or minimal changes
May not cite the original source, thus, it’s a form of plagiarism Includes information without changing the original text
Can maintain the same idea with unique structure May incorrectly provide an author’s name, still considered plagiarism
Uses synonyms to describe concepts Often disregards the aspect of using synonyms

Example:

In this example, the plagiarized text restates the main idea without proper citation, attributing it to Jones et al. (2021). This constitutes plagiarism as the idea is not properly credited to the original authors and even the citation is absent in the first example.

When to Paraphrase?

When paraphrasing, it’s crucial to convey the original message in your own words while ensuring proper citation to avoid plagiarism. Paraphrasing serves several purposes, including improving word choice, changing the subject matter, avoiding overuse of quotes, addressing problematic language, and shortening lengthy quotes. By paraphrasing effectively, writers can maintain the integrity of their work while incorporating external sources to enhance their arguments and insights.

Example:

Attempt 1 and Attempt 2 demonstrate plagiarism because they either directly copy the original text or merely alter it slightly without providing adequate citation. In contrast, Attempt 3 successfully paraphrases the original passage by restating the ideas in different words while crediting the source, (Smith et al., 2020).

Since it is crucial to check the similarity index to avoid plagiarism as paraphrasing is a creative process. Consider using a plagiarism checker to evaluate your written content in terms of similarities and plagiarism risks. 

How to Paraphrase Effectively

Paraphrasing is a crucial skill for academic writing, serving as one of the primary methods to avoid plagiarism. However, effective paraphrasing goes beyond merely replacing words with synonyms. It involves skillful manipulation of language to convey the original idea in a new form while maintaining clarity and integrity. Here are some strategies and guidelines for paraphrasing effectively:

  • Change Parts of Speech

Modifying the grammatical structure of sentences offers a fresh perspective and enhances the richness of paraphrased content. This technique fosters creativity and clarity in conveying the original message. For example:

Original text: “The eagle gracefully soared across the azure sky, scanning the landscape below for its next meal.”

Paraphrase: Due to its remarkable aerial ability, the eagle surveyed the earth for its next prey by ascending to great heights.

  • Rearrange the Structure

Changing the order of phrases and clauses creates fresh and engaging sentences. This technique enhances readability while preserving the original meaning. For example:

Original text: “The annual rainfall in the region averages around 50 inches per year.” 

Paraphrase: The region receives an average rainfall of approximately 50 inches every year.

  • Incorporate additional analysis

Adding this strategy into paraphrasing involves going beyond merely restating the original text and providing further insight or interpretation. This can enhance the understanding and depth of the paraphrased content. For instance:

Original text: “The unemployment rate in the country has dropped to 4%.”

Paraphrase: Recent data indicates that the unemployment rate in the country has declined to 4%, signaling positive economic growth and potentially improving prospects for job seekers.

  • Trim unnecessary information

This paraphrasing technique involves adjusting the original text by either removing irrelevant parts or adding personal insights to improve relevance and coherence. By trimming unnecessary details or integrating additional analysis, the paraphrased content maintains focus while enhancing its overall clarity and impact. For example:

Original text: “The research study found a significant correlation between sleep duration and cognitive function in adults over the age of 50.”

Paraphrase: The comprehensive research investigation revealed a noteworthy association between the duration of sleep and cognitive performance among adults aged 50 and above, emphasizing the importance of adequate rest for maintaining optimal brain health.

Apart from the above-mentioned tips, paraphrasing can also be enhanced by reading sections aloud, using paraphrasing tools, and explaining the author’s idea to a friend, ensuring clarity. However, it’s important to compare the paraphrase with the original to maintain accuracy in conveying essential information in a new form.

6 Tips to Avoid Plagiarism while Paraphrasing

Avoiding improper paraphrasing is crucial to maintaining academic integrity and avoiding plagiarism. Here are six steps to help writers steer clear of common pitfalls:

  • Check the Source: Before paraphrasing, verify the credibility and timeliness of the original content to ensure accurate and up-to-date information.
  • Understand the Content: Fully grasp the meaning of the text by reading it multiple times and researching any unclear terms to paraphrase effectively.
  • Use Quotation Marks: When directly quoting unique words or phrases from the original content, use quotation marks to distinguish them and maintain accuracy.
  • Compare Paraphrase with Original: After paraphrasing, compare the new version with the original to ensure it captures the essence without mimicking the wording.
  • Cite All Sources: Provide proper citations for all paraphrased content to acknowledge the original author or source and avoid plagiarism.
  • Utilize Plagiarism Checkers: Use plagiarism detection tools to verify the originality of paraphrased content and ensure proper citation and attribution.

 Conclusion

In simple words, understanding the difference between good and bad paraphrasing is important for being honest and ethical in academic writing. Paraphrasing means putting something in your own words, which helps explain tricky ideas and make things clear. But it’s only effective if you do it carefully.

Proper paraphrasing means taking someone else’s ideas and explaining them in a new way, while also giving credit to the source. This shows that you respect the work of others and helps to keep your own work honest. On the other hand, improper paraphrasing is like copying someone else’s work and pretending it’s your own, which is called plagiarism. It’s not fair to the original author and can get you in trouble.

By following some simple tips and being careful, you can avoid the pitfalls of bad paraphrasing and make sure your work is original and honest. Also, using tools like Skyline Academic can check your work for any mistakes.